Round #6 - Challenge #6 - Results

[hermionesparkle.livejournal.com]

Thank you for all of the votes! It is getting tougher to see people go now.

Eliminated:
by pirateveronica with -3 votes

Sorry to see you go!

Community's Choice:
by winter_rogue
&
by dance_the_dance with +2 votes (banner coming at the end of the round)

Chosen One (mod's choice):
by evangelin1202. I liked the text work and the position of the text. (banner coming at the end of the round)


Tally
- indicts negative, + indicts positive.

If you can't remember what # you were, refer to the voting post.

#1. -4, +1 = +3 Eliminated
#2. -1, +3 = +2 Community's Choice
#3. -2, +1 = -1 Chosen One
#4. -0, +2 = +2 Community's Choice

Leave a comment if you want your comments.

Comments

[hermionesparkle.livejournal.com]

Well it gets so hard when there are so few left. :\

negative:
1 - The concept is nice but the coloring lacks in contrast. The rest is nice though.
#1 - The icon is really washed out. Could use some vibrance and contrast.
#1 - The texture just doesn't work and the top image is so washed out.
#01- the colors & contrast are fairly washed out in the top section and the test is both unreadable and distracting from the subject.

positive:
#1 - Nice composition and nice soft coloring. I'd just suggest some more contrast.

[winter-rogue.livejournal.com]

thanks to everyone who voted!

can I get the negative comment for #2?

[hermionesparkle.livejournal.com]

Sure. You don't want the positive ones as well?

negative:
#2 - The icon needs more contrast and lightening and maybe a texture or something to bring more 'action' into it.

[evangelin1202.livejournal.com]

Thank you!! May I have my comments?

And damn, I really liked that B/G icon. Most of the time I really don't get people.

[hermionesparkle.livejournal.com]

Negative:
#3 - too dark, and the text is just awkwardly placed.
3 - the blending around the icon is odd, there isn't enough of a separation between the background and the subjects, esp when using this technique.

Positive:
#3 - Lovely coloring.