All in! Yay! Great entries everyone!
Rules:1. Keep your icon identity hidden until after the results are posted. Don't vote for yourself or get anybody to vote for you.
2. Vote on quality, not preference. Actually think about why you are voting the icons out. It's to plain, to sharp, or it's boring are not good enough reasons to vote an icon out. If your opinion is that the icon is to dark, explain where and/or why is it to dark. Be specific without being nasty. Examples on how to vote are under the cut as is a few links of helpful tips.
3. Vote for
1 icon that you feel is the worst quality of the bunch. You are also voting for
1 favorite icon. Voting is weighed.
4. If you entered, please vote. It helps keeping things fair.
( voting under the cut for challenge #10 )Voting will end Monday March 21st at around 10PM EDT. Waiting for the tie to be broken.