Round #2 - Challenge #1 - Results

[hermionesparkle.livejournal.com]

Thanks for everyone who voted!! This was a close one.

Eliminated:
by lorespuff with -3 votes

Sorry to see you go first. I hope you'll stick around for voting & keep an eye out for the comeback challenge which will be within the next few weeks!

Community's Choice:
by darlaslilgirl with 3 votes (banner)

Chosen One (mod's choice):
by coffee_scented. Unique crop & lovely clear coloring. (banner)


Tally
- indicts negative, + indicts positive.

if you can't remember what # you were, refer to the voting post.

#1. -2, +1 = -1
#2. -3, +1 = -2
#3. -2, +0 = -2
#4. -0, +2 = +2 Community's Choice
#5. -0, +1 = +1 Chosen One
#6. -3, +0 = -3 Eliminated
#7. -0, +0 = 0
#8. -2, +2 = 0
#9. -2, +0 = -2
#10. -1, +0 = -1

Leave a comment if you want your comments.

Comments

[shadowsong-13.livejournal.com]

Comments for #3 please?

[hermionesparkle.livejournal.com]

#3 - The crop is a little awkward and the cut out doesn't seem to fit. The image is also a bit dark.

#3 - the concept is nice but the outline behind the main image is distracting and the main image could be brighter to make it pop more.

:)