2 least quality icons: #7 - reason- I think the artist was going for an artistic shadow icon but the icon is too dark and has too much contrast. Because of the darkness and contrast, you can barely make out Spike and Buffy's face. Although I do light the lighting around Buffy. #2 - reason - I like the negative space and center crop on this one but the icon is too dark and the texture chosen looks pixelated. I think the background would have worked better if the artist did it in a greyscale gradient instead.
1 best quality icon #6 - reason- This icon is not only very well done technically, it is very well done artistically.
no subject
#7 - reason- I think the artist was going for an artistic shadow icon but the icon is too dark and has too much contrast. Because of the darkness and contrast, you can barely make out Spike and Buffy's face. Although I do light the lighting around Buffy.
#2 - reason - I like the negative space and center crop on this one but the icon is too dark and the texture chosen looks pixelated. I think the background would have worked better if the artist did it in a greyscale gradient instead.
1 best quality icon
#6 - reason- This icon is not only very well done technically, it is very well done artistically.